Malindi Dishes Ordered to Compensate Unfairly Dismissed Staff After Employees Accuse Management of Malpractice and a Toxic Work Environment
The employees at Malindi Dishes in Nairobi, who have endured hardships for many years, have finally decided to voice their concerns and declare that they can no longer tolerate the situation.
In a conversation with us,
under strict anonymity due to fears of retaliation, several staff members have
described their workplace as toxic. They accuse the management of being
high-handed, arrogant, and employing coercion, threats, and intimidation
against those who hold differing opinions.
They assert that they are
required to work extended hours without receiving overtime pay, are compensated
with meager salaries, and do not receive any leave or time off, despite
statutory deductions being taken from their pay without being remitted.
Additionally, employees
are dismissed on trivial grounds, as exemplified by the case of Bashir Ali
Shuriya, who was unjustly terminated and subsequently had to file a lawsuit
against the company at the Nairobi Employment and Labour Relations Court.
Shuriya asserts that he
was employed by the Malindi Dishes as a cashier with an agreed monthly salary
of Kshs. 30,000. He states that his employment with the Respondent spanned from
April 2021 to May 2022, and then from November 2022 to January 2025, with the
gap in between due to health issues related to ear problems.
Additionally, he claims
that during his employment, he was occasionally assigned tasks beyond his
primary role as a cashier. The Claimant maintains that throughout his tenure
with the Respondent, he received no complaints, faced no disciplinary actions,
and demonstrated dedication and loyalty in his work.
He argues that he did not
abandon his duties and was present at his workplace when the Respondent
terminated his services in January 2025 without prior notice. Following his
termination, he did not receive any terminal payments, including his salary for
January 2025.
he contends that
throughout his employment, he was never granted leave and worked during public
holidays. Moreover, although he did not receive a house allowance, he was
provided accommodation in a hostel by the Malindi Dishes. he reported the issue
to the Labour Office in Nairobi, where a labour officer calculated his claim to
include his January 2025 salary, one month's notice pay, compensation for
accrued leave days, and twelve (12) months' salary for unfair termination. He
states that after his advocates made a demand, the management, through their
advocate, claimed that the Claimant had absconded from duty, an assertion the
Claimant refutes, and further claimed that his dues were left at the Nairobi
Labour Office.
The management asserts
that the Respondent was summoned by the labour officer but failed to attend the
scheduled joint meeting, later appearing alone in the absence of Shuriya, and
subsequently claimed that Shuriya case had been dismissed, which the he
disputes.
he asserts that his
dismissal occurred without notice, without justification, and without the
payment of any severance benefits. Consequently, this action is inconsistent
with fair labor practices and infringes upon his labor and constitutional
rights.
THE
JUDGEMENT
It
is therefore the onus of the respondent to prove that the salary of the
claimant was all inclusive as averred and that the claimant absconded duty. The
respondent has unfortunately not discharged this duty.
There is no evidence that even if the claimant had absconded duty he was sought after and subjected
to a disciplinary hearing on the ground of absconding.
There being no such evidence, I find that the claimant was unfairly terminated and I find for him and given the fact the he was treated unfairly without a hearing, I find 6 months compensation as reasonable which:
(1) I award him = 6 x 30,000 = 180,000.
(2) 1 month salary in lieu of notice = kshs 30,000/-
(3) Compensation for leave days not taken as admitted
by the respondent = kshs 30,000/-.
(4) Salary for January 2025 not paid = kshs 30,000/-.
(5) Leave allowance not paid for 2 years (2022/2023 &
2023/2024= 21 days per year = 41 days =
41/30x30,000= Kshs 41,000/-.
Total Awarded Kshs 311,000/-. Less statutory deductions
Dated, Signed and Delivered Virtually at Nairobi this
2nd Day of July, 2026.
HELLEN WASILWA
JUDGE

Comments
Post a Comment